Blog

A friend of mine who writes for The New York Times recently called me “cynical but insightful.” I took it as a compliment, though I’d rather be known as trusting, loving, caring, and giving, of course.

But cynicism is probably the best lens in which to view the announcement of the new U.S. Senator representing the nation’s largest Asian American population.

California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s appointment of Laphonza Butler to replace the late, great Dianne Feinstein, who passed away last week, was the best choice for him.

Just not for Californians, not for Asian Americans in California, and not for the nation.

No knock on Butler, who is the president of Emily’s List and an experienced political operative. But Newsom used her to bail him out of a corner of his own making.

Newsom had made a promise after he filled the vacated senate seat of Kamala Harris with a Latinx male. He vowed his next Senate appointment would be a Black female.

All good. But earlier this year, when Feinstein announced she would not run again, no fewer than three Democrats jumped in the ring. Rep. Adam Schiff, of impeachment fame, was the implied favorite of Feinstein. Then there was Rep. Katie Porter, a darling of the left. The only Black female to announce was the revered former chair of the Congressional Black Caucus, Calif. Rep. Barbara Lee, also known for being the only member of Congress to refuse to authorize military action in Afghanistan in 2001. She’s a progressive to be reckoned with.

Of the three announced candidates, Lee was the only one to fulfill Newsom’s promise. She’s a formidable Black legislator who knows how Congress works from the inside out. Lee would have been a senator who would hit the ground running.

Barbara Lee was the best choice for California and the nation.

She just wasn’t the best choice for Gavin Newsom.

The best choice for Gavin Newsom was. . .Laphonza Butler.

She’s the best H.R. choice to avoid any pushback. Who’s going to argue about an African American lesbian who is also aformer union leader for nurses and caretakers?

It was a godsend for Newsom.

Instead of being forced to choose from the three announced candidates for the Feinstein seat, Newsom sought the best Black woman to fulfill his promise.

Just not necessarily the best person for the job.

Butler hasn’t been an elected official. She hasn’t passed legislation. She is political, yes. And she’s served as a member of the University of California Board of Regents, despite having no experience in higher education. But she learned on the job, and that’s what she’ll do in the Senate.

Reports say this was not a “caretaker” position. Butler is not just filling out Feinstein’s time and then stepping down. Butler will be senator and can run again in 2024--as an incumbent.

And that was Newsom’s formidable gift to Butler. She would be a sitting senator, appointed by the governor.

Picking Butler also garners loyalty and fealty to Newsom for as long as necessary. It is Newsom’s enduring benefit to have birthed a lifelong ally personally placed in the senate.

Genius move by Newsom? Certainly, the Butler pick served Newsom much more than the people of California.

Instead of making a choice that would show leadership as well as integrity by choosing Barbara Lee, Newsom did what was best for him.

It’s disappointing. I’ve known Newsom since his days as a San Francisco supervisor. As he terms out as governor, his star has been rising in the last few months as a Biden surrogate. But Newsom always seems to try too hard to get it right.Like his hair. Like his Butler pick.

A little too calculated, political, and cynical.

Of course, he could have picked an Asian American to be senator for the most Asian American state in the nation. But he hadn’t made that promise. Most Asian Americans in California were more than fine with the possibility of a Senator Lee.

But that wasn’t to be Newsom’s choice.

The saving grace for the Dems is that Newsom’s filling of the Feinstein vacancy isn’t even the most newsworthy event of the week. In an historic vote on Tuesday, the Republican Party led by eight MAGA extremists just ousted its own House Speaker Kevin McCarthy of Bakersfield.

Now the Republicans are leaderless in the House, while the head of the party, former president Donald Trump, is on trial in New York for fraud. The Republicans are fast becoming the party of chaos and dysfunction.

And the Democrats? At least, they look orderly with Newsom’s pick of Laphonza Butler.

FEINSTEIN’S PASSING

Regular readers know I have been a vocal proponent against what I perceived as an ageist reaction to Feinstein. I simply thought she earned the right to leave politics on her own terms. See https://www.aaldef.org/blog/emil-guillermo-california-asian-americans-should-revere-the-leadership-of-sen.dianne-feinstein/

I was aware of all the stories about her the last few years. But to the very end, she managed to fulfill her duties and serve the people of California well. Remember, the senate is all about seniority. That is the open secret about the senate. And now with her passing, how many people anywhere can even name the state’s two senators without resorting to Google?

Because of seniority, Feinstein had more power in her pinky finger. And now all that is lost.

As a reporter covering Feinstein over the years, I will never forget the times she stepped back from our journalist/politician roles to simply acknowledge me as a person and human being. It was a kindness you don’t expect. But she knew I wasn’t just some badgering guy with a microphone.

And then there was the time we shared a stage at a Lowell High School commencement in the 1980s. I spoke before her as the graduate turned local TV journalist who made good. My speech was memorable and funny, as I used a toilet plunger as a prop. At least, I thought it was funny. If I lost a segment of the audience, Feinstein knew how to win them all back. She was like a cheerleader full of life and in minutes had the whole auditorium at her beck and call. That was the political leader in action. To see a moment of Feinstein’s charismatic power, years before her ascent to the senate, was an honor to witness.

# # #
NOTE: I will talk about this column and other matters on “Emil Amok’s Takeout,” my AAPI micro-talk show. Live @2p Pacific. Livestream on Facebook; my YouTube channel; and Twitter. Catch the recordings on www.amok.com.