City Rescinds Thousands in Illegal Chinatown BID Fees After property Owners Protest

Tuesday, Apr 10, 2012

BID press picture.jpgThe Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund (AALDEF), the Property Tax Payers' Association, and small property owners in Chinatown announced that New York City's Department of Finance and Department of Small Business Services have admitted that property owners were wrongfully charged several hundred thousand in Business Improvement District (BID) fees.

After the City Council voted to increase fees on Chinatown properties by establishing a BID, despite the protests of property owners already crippled by the current recession, the Department of Finance held the same property owners responsible for thousands of dollars in BID fees for four months before it was even in place.

"We maintained from the start that the Chinatown property owners were being charged unlawfully for the BID," said Bethany Li, staff attorney at AALDEF. "The hundreds of thousands of dollars involved is a huge sum of money for small property and business owners. Only after these small property owners stood up for themselves did the City admit its mistake."

AALDEF sent a letter to the Department of Finance and the Chinatown BID Interim Board asking that the City rescind these unlawful, retroactive charges. Upon receiving no response, AALDEF prepared to take legal action on behalf of the Property Tax Payers' Association, a group formed to protect the rights of small property owners in Chinatown. On March 20, they held a press conference in a vacant Chinatown storefront on the need for corrective action. According to news reports, at least one BID-related official claimed there was no error.

On March 30, the Department of Small Business Services acknowledged that the fees were wrongfully charged and agreed to rescind them without a lawsuit. Property owners who paid the amount will be reimbursed, and those who have not paid will not be penalized until the City recalculates the fees in the next billing cycle.

"Considering the historic number of objections to the BID, there was an expectation that the BID would have enough oversight to prevent such wrongful charges," said Jan Lee, a Chinatown property owner, who was charged $2,200 in BID fees for his properties. "This lack of oversight is one of the reasons why we opposed the BID. Despite all the city officials involved, the burden of oversight is falling to us property owners who can least afford it."

The property owners have also raised the issue of whether the Chinatown BID Interim Board could vote to use future BID fees to reimburse the Chinatown Partnership Local Development Corporation, which claims to have spent money on BID services before the BID existed and before the BID board signed any contracts with outside entities. "The BID has already shown that it is mismanaging our money," said Irving Lee, a Chinatown property owner. "The BID is requiring us to be extremely vigilant in protecting ourselves from illegal charges."


  • Bethany Li     212.966.5932 ex. 213

  • Ujala Sehgal    646.207.1497


Preliminary results of AALDEF exit poll of more than 7,600 Asian American voters in midterm elections


AALDEF to conduct Asian American Exit Poll and monitor poll sites in 14 states


AALDEF criticizes Trump's intention to end birthright citizenship by executive order


AALDEF stands in solidarity with Pittsburgh and Louisville


Volunteers needed for AALDEF Asian American Exit Poll and to monitor polling places in 2018 elections


AALDEF denounces White House plan to redefine "public charge" for immigrants seeking green cards


Sept. 12: AALDEF legal director Ken Kimerling receives 2018 New York County Lawyers Association Public Service Award


35 Asian American groups and higher ed faculty file amicus brief in support of race-conscious admissions at Harvard


AALDEF statement on Judge Brett Kavanaugh's nomination to the Supreme Court


AALDEF deplores the Supreme Court's decision upholding the Muslim ban


Korean and Latino workers at Kum Gang San restaurants win enforcement of $2.7 million wage theft judgment


AALDEF opposes Trump administration's politicization of Census 2020 by adding citizenship question


2017 AALDEF exit poll: 2,538 Asian American voters polled in 4 states: VA, NJ, NY, MA


Federal appeals court upholds ruling in AALDEF case that Texas election law violates Voting Rights Act