Asian Americans Urge Federal Appeals Court to Affirm Illegality of Arizona's Discriminatory Voter Proof of Citizenship Law

Wednesday, Jun 8, 2011

The Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund (AALDEF), with pro bono co-counsel Milbank, Tweed, Hadley & McCloy LLP, filed an amicus "friend of the court" brief in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in Gonzalez v. Arizona, challenging the legality of Proposition 200, Arizona's restrictive voter proof of citizenship law passed in 2004.

On October 26, 2010, a three-judge panel in the Ninth Circuit struck down the law, finding the requirement that new voters present proof of United States citizenship violated the National Voter Registration Act. (Gonzalez v. Arizona, 624 F.3d 1162 (9th Cir. 2010)) On April 27, 2011, the Court granted a re-hearing en banc, with the full Ninth Circuit considering the case.  Argument is scheduled for June 20.

The amicus brief contends that Proposition 200 violates the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA).  Congress enacted the NVRA to promote voter registration and to eliminate state-imposed voting requirements because they "disproportionately harm[ed] voter participation by various groups including racial minorities."  

Proposition 200 mandates a burdensome and unequal voting requirement on non-citizens.  While native-born citizens may mail copies of their U.S. birth certificates with their voter registration applications, naturalized citizens do not have the same option and may only provide naturalization certificates in person, not by mail.  

Asian Americans are disproportionately affected by proof of citizenship requirements because a high percentage of them are naturalized citizens. Of the approximately 126,497 Asian Americans living in Arizona, 51,370 are foreign-born naturalized citizens. Potentially 40% of the Asian American community may encounter the barriers of Proposition 200 when attempting to register to vote. By contrast, only 3.5% of White Americans are foreign-born naturalized citizens, with few burdened by Proposition 200.  

Glenn D. Magpantay, AALDEF Democracy Program director, said, "All eligible citizens, either naturalized or native-born, should have equal access to the electoral process.  The barriers naturalized citizens encounter as a result of Proposition 200 run contrary to the  NVRA, which seeks to eliminate such barriers to voting."  

AALDEF's amicus brief in the Gonzalez re-hearing can be found here.


Census Bureau releases new list of counties requiring Asian-language assistance under the Voting Rights Act


AALDEF exit poll reveals new data on Muslim voter discrimination and GOP crossover voting for Clinton


After the 2016 presidential election, the fight for DACA and immigrant rights will continue


American Muslim voters faced extra hurdles at poll sites in Michigan & NY in the 2016 elections


In AALDEF's Election Day exit poll of Asian American voters, Clinton favored over Trump by wide margin


Despite high turnout, Asian American voters faced barriers to voting on Election Day


AALDEF to poll 10,000 Asian American voters in 14 states on Election Day


AALDEF criticizes Fox News for racist Chinatown segment on "The O'Reilly Report"


Oct. 4: Joyce Xi talks about racial profiling & the wrongful prosecution of Chinese American scientists


Sept 29: AMPLIFY(HER) zine launch at Asian American Writers Workshop


Sept 6 rally: AALDEF Statement on NY Supreme Court Justice Doris Ling-Cohan


Federal court blocks Texas law restricting language assistance to voters


Remembering Grace Hwang, 1956-2016


National Asian American groups applaud Supreme Court decision in Fisher II affirmative action case