Asian American Groups File Response to PA Attorney General's Motion to Disregard their Amicus Brief

Friday, Sep 20, 2013

September 20, 2013 -- The Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund (AALDEF) and the Asian Pacific American Bar Association (APABA) of Pennsylvania filed a response today to the Pennsylvania State Attorney General's motion to disregard their amicus brief in the PA voter ID case Applewhite v. Pennsylvania.

"The steps taken by state attorneys to disregard the brief are highly unusual," said Jerry Vattamala, staff attorney at AALDEF. "Our brief, which demonstrates that PA's new voter ID law would disenfranchise Asian Americans at a disproportionately high rate, must be taken into account by the Court in making a decision that affects the fundamental voting rights of so many Asian Americans."

AALDEF's amicus brief, properly filed in the PA State Supreme Court, is based on findings from AALDEF's election monitoring data from 2012 and prior elections. The brief provides evidence from AALDEF's poll monitoring that PA's new voter ID law would continue to lead to overt or implicit discrimination against Asian Americans at the polls. Moreover, it contends that the Commonwealth has made no significant attempt to provide Asian American citizens of limited English proficiency with information about the new voting law. Read more about the brief here >

The amicus brief was filed on August 30, 2013. On September 6, attorneys for PA took the unusual steps of (1) filing a motion to disregard the amicus brief and (2) in the same motion, attempted to rebut the arguments made in the amicus brief.

The response to the motion was prepared by AALDEF, APABA-PA, and pro-bono counsel White & Case LLP.

Download the response to the motion to disregard here >

Ujala Sehgal
212.966.5932 x.217


Census Bureau releases new list of counties requiring Asian-language assistance under the Voting Rights Act


AALDEF exit poll reveals new data on Muslim voter discrimination and GOP crossover voting for Clinton


After the 2016 presidential election, the fight for DACA and immigrant rights will continue


American Muslim voters faced extra hurdles at poll sites in Michigan & NY in the 2016 elections


In AALDEF's Election Day exit poll of Asian American voters, Clinton favored over Trump by wide margin


Despite high turnout, Asian American voters faced barriers to voting on Election Day


AALDEF to poll 10,000 Asian American voters in 14 states on Election Day


AALDEF criticizes Fox News for racist Chinatown segment on "The O'Reilly Report"


Oct. 4: Joyce Xi talks about racial profiling & the wrongful prosecution of Chinese American scientists


Sept 29: AMPLIFY(HER) zine launch at Asian American Writers Workshop


Sept 6 rally: AALDEF Statement on NY Supreme Court Justice Doris Ling-Cohan


Federal court blocks Texas law restricting language assistance to voters


Remembering Grace Hwang, 1956-2016


National Asian American groups applaud Supreme Court decision in Fisher II affirmative action case